Announcement: Introducing iLumOS by Lumenci: Expert-Powered AI Platform for Patent Intelligence

Technical Analysis in Inter Partes Review: What Petitioners and Patent Owners Need to Prove 

An inter partes review (IPR) is a proceeding before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) of the USPTO in which a petitioner challenges the patentability of issued claims for anticipation under 35 U.S.C. § 102 or obviousness under § 103, using only patents and printed publications as prior art (35 U.S.C. § 311(b)). Anticipation asks whether a single earlier reference discloses every limitation of a claim. Obviousness asks whether the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious to a person having ordinary skill in the art. 

Finding the right prior art is only the beginning. The outcome usually turns on how convincingly each side interprets the claims, establishes what the references actually disclose, explains or attacks proposed combinations, and backs its positions with technical evidence and expert testimony. 

This article covers those technical questions, from both the patent owner’s and the petitioner’s side. For the earlier search stage, see Lumenci’s guide to patent validity search and patent invalidity analysis.

Key Takeaways

  • Since October 20, 2025, the USPTO Director decides whether to institute an IPR, weighing discretionary factors alongside the merits. Institution is now a strategic hurdle of its own. 
  • Once a trial is instituted, the technical record decides it: claim construction, the skilled person, limitation-by-limitation mapping, motivation to combine, nexus, and substitute claims. 
  • Petitioners must locate every claim limitation in a patent or printed publication and give a reasoned basis for any combination. 
  • Patent owners win by exposing unsupported inferences, showing why a combination would not work, and tying objective evidence to the claims through nexus. 
  • Expert testimony that does not disclose its underlying facts or data gets little or no weight, so the declaration has to show its work.

How PTAB Proceedings Changed in 2025 and 2026: Institution and the Technical Record

The USPTO’s approach to IPR institution changed substantially in 2025 and 2026. Institution is the decision to start an IPR trial after evaluating a petition. It is separate from the final decision on patentability. 

On March 26, 2025, the USPTO introduced an interim process that separated discretionary institution considerations from the merits. Under the October 17, 2025 memorandum, effective October 20, 2025, the Director took over institution decisions, weighing discretionary factors, the merits, and other considerations in consultation with at least three PTAB judges. Instituted proceedings go to a three-member PTAB panel for trial. 

Discretionary denial means the Director may decline to institute review for reasons beyond the strength of the unpatentability challenge. A petition can raise serious technical questions and still not proceed. 

The framework kept moving in 2026. On March 11, 2026, the USPTO announced additional discretionary considerations covering U.S. manufacturing operations, related investment, and small-business petitioners sued for infringement. Parties now have to address these factors alongside their technical arguments. 

Separately, the USPTO published an October 17, 2025 proposed rule that would add new bars to IPR institution. A proposed rule is not binding. A final version went to White House regulatory review in July 2026, but its text had not been published at the time of writing, so check its status before relying on it. 

These changes make institution a strategic question in its own right. Once a trial is instituted, though, the strength of the technical record still decides the final patentability determination. 

Claim Construction: Establishing What the Claims Actually Require

Patent owner: Claim construction is often the first place technical analysis changes the case. The PTAB applies the same standard used in a civil action under 35 U.S.C. § 282(b): the ordinary and customary meaning to a person of ordinary skill in the art, read in light of the claim language, specification, prosecution history, and relevant extrinsic evidence (37 C.F.R. § 42.100(b)). The patent owner needs more than a favorable definition. It needs a technically coherent explanation of why the specification, drawings, terminology, and prosecution history support that reading. 

Petitioner: The petitioner needs a construction that makes its prior art analysis legally and technically meaningful. It must explain how the construed claim is unpatentable and where each element is found in the cited patents or publications, as 37 C.F.R. § 42.104(b)(3) to (b)(5) requires. 

Parallel litigation makes consistency essential. In Ford Motor Co. v. AutoConnect Holdings LLC, IPR2025-01342, Paper 27 (May 12, 2026), the Director vacated institution because the petitioner had advanced indefiniteness arguments in the co-pending district court case without sufficient justification. The USPTO later designated the decision informative. For how expert positions are tested under questioning, see Lumenci’s guide to expert witness testimony. 

Build Your IP Case with
the Right Experts
Image link

The Skilled Person: Defining the Relevant Technical Knowledge

Patent owner: A person having ordinary skill in the art (POSITA) is a hypothetical individual with the ordinary technical knowledge and capabilities relevant to the invention. That person’s level of skill shapes how the prior art is read and whether a proposed modification would have been obvious. Under Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1 (1966), the level of ordinary skill is one of the underlying factual questions in any obviousness analysis. Patent owners can challenge unsupported assumptions about the skilled person’s education, practical experience, familiarity with particular technologies, and ability to solve specific technical problems. 

Petitioner: The proposed level of skill must reflect the relevant field and the knowledge reasonably available at the relevant time. Expert testimony should establish why the skilled person would have understood the cited disclosures and had the capabilities attributed to them. A poorly supported skill level can break the reasoning that connects the prior art to the challenged claims. 

Prior Art Mapping for Patent Claims: Testing Every Limitation

Patent owner: The critical question is whether the cited references actually disclose the claimed technical features. A reference describing a similar function does not necessarily disclose the particular architecture, sequence, or relationship the claim requires. For anticipation, a single reference must disclose every limitation, expressly or inherently, arranged as in the claim. Inherency requires that the missing feature necessarily be present, not merely that it could be. 

Take a hypothetical software claim requiring authentication, generation of a temporary token, and validation of that token before access is granted. A reference that discusses authentication and token validation separately may not disclose the claimed sequence. Patent owners should examine each cited passage, identify unsupported inferences, and separate what the reference actually says from the petitioner’s reading of it. 

Petitioner: The mapping must show where every limitation is disclosed, with precise citations to the supporting passages, figures, and technical descriptions. 37 C.F.R. § 42.104(b)(4) and (b)(5) expressly require the petition to identify where each element is found and the evidence supporting the challenge. Claim charts are especially useful here because they tie each claim limitation to its evidence and expose gaps or inconsistent readings. Lumenci’s guide to patent claim analysis covers element-by-element comparison in more depth. 

Prior Art Search
Services
prior art searches by lumenci

Motivation to Combine: Establishing Why References Would Be Combined

Patent owner: In an obviousness challenge built on multiple references, finding the individual claim elements is not enough. The petitioner must show why the skilled person would have combined or modified the references to arrive at the claimed invention. In KSR International Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007), the Supreme Court rejected a rigid requirement for an explicit teaching, suggestion, or motivation to combine, but obviousness must still rest on an articulated rationale supported by the record. Patent owners can challenge a combination by showing that a reference teaches away from it, that the modification would undermine the reference’s intended operation, or that the skilled person would have had no reasonable expectation of success. These objections need technical evidence, not general claims of incompatibility. 

Petitioner: The analysis should explain the technical problem being addressed, what each reference teaches, and why the skilled person would have made the proposed combination. The mere possibility of combining two technologies is not a rationale. A credible analysis ties the combination to the skilled person’s knowledge, recognized technical needs, and expected results, without hindsight drawn from the patent itself. This is where patent invalidity analysis has to move past search results into defensible technical reasoning. 

Objective Evidence and Nexus: Connecting Commercial Evidence to the Invention

Patent owner: Objective evidence of non-obviousness, such as commercial success, copying, industry praise, and long-felt but unresolved need, can help counter an obviousness challenge. The essential requirement is nexus: a legally sufficient connection between that evidence and the claimed invention. Commercial success alone does not show the success came from the patented technology. It may instead reflect branding, distribution, pricing, or significant unclaimed features. 

The PTAB’s precedential decision in Lectrosonics, Inc. v. Zaxcom, Inc., IPR2018-01129, Paper 33 (Jan. 24, 2020), shows nexus deciding the result: the Board found the original claims unpatentable but granted the patent owner’s motion to amend because the substitute claims had a sufficient nexus to its objective evidence. In Manufacturing Resources International, Inc. v. Squires (Fed. Cir. Mar. 31, 2026) (nonprecedential), the court held the patent owner was not entitled to a presumption of nexus because it never showed the accused commercial displays were coextensive with the claims, and the products included unclaimed features whose role in their success went unaddressed. 

Reverse engineering, product teardown, and technical testing can establish whether a commercial product practices the claimed features. In Manufacturing Resources, the patent owner built its nexus argument around the opposing party’s teardown of a competing product, and the argument failed because the Board found the accused products had been designed before that teardown. Proving claim coverage does not automatically prove that commercial success came from those features. 

Lumenci’s reverse engineering and product testing work documents how products implement the claimed invention, which is the technical foundation a nexus argument needs. Products themselves still cannot serve as prior art in an IPR under 35 U.S.C. § 311(b). 

Petitioner: The response can focus on whether the claimed success or copying is attributable to the claimed invention, whether significant unclaimed features drove commercial performance, and whether the evidence establishes the required nexus at all. 

Amended and Substitute Claims

Patent owner: Under 35 U.S.C. § 316(d), a patent owner may move to cancel challenged claims or propose a reasonable number of substitute claims. Substitute claims are replacement claims proposed during the IPR. They cannot enlarge claim scope or introduce new matter. The technical work has two jobs: show written-description support for the amended language and show why the amended claim survives the asserted prior art. Under 37 C.F.R. § 42.121, the patent owner bears the burden on several amendment requirements, while the petitioner bears the burden of persuasion to show the substitute claims are unpatentable. 

Petitioner: Test every added limitation against the cited references and any additional evidence properly before the Board. A substitute claim is not safe just because it is narrower. The analysis has to show where the new limitation comes from and why the amended combination remains unpatentable. 

Expert Declarations: Turning Technical Analysis into Defensible Testimony

The expert declaration is often the document that connects technical evidence to the patentability arguments. Under 37 C.F.R. § 42.65(a), expert testimony that does not disclose the underlying facts or data supporting the opinion gets little or no weight. The declaration should show how the expert reached each material conclusion, not just state that a claim is or is not disclosed or obvious. In Xerox Corp. v. Bytemark, Inc., IPR2022-00624, Paper 9 (Aug. 24, 2022) (precedential), the Board denied institution in part because the expert’s declaration repeated the petition’s conclusory assertions without supporting evidence. 

A declaration that holds up is grounded in the record: the claim language, specification, prior art disclosures, technical evidence, and any testing or data relied on. It explains the expert’s assumptions, methodology, and reasoning clearly enough that another technical reader can follow the analysis without filling in missing steps. 

It must also be written with deposition in mind. Under 37 C.F.R. § 42.53, direct testimony is generally submitted by declaration, while cross-examination is taken by deposition. The expert has to explain and defend each assumption, conclusion, and piece of supporting evidence under questioning. The strongest IPR declaration is not the longest one. It is the one where every important opinion has a clear evidentiary foundation and a chain of reasoning that survives cross-examination. 

The Technical Record at a Glance

inter partes review

How Lumenci Builds the Technical Record for Both Sides of an IPR

Lumenci supports patent owners defending their claims and petitioners challenging them, with engineers who work in the technology at issue and an expert network that can testify to it. 

  • Limitation-by-limitation claim charts. For patent owners, Lumenci tests the petitioner’s mapping against what each reference actually discloses. For petitioners, it builds claim charts that cite the exact passage and figure behind every limitation. 
  • Invalidity search that goes past the obvious references. Lumenci’s prior art search team runs invalidity searches for IPRs and litigation and adds motivation-to-combine analysis wherever a ground relies on combined references. 
  • Product evidence for nexus. Reverse engineering and product testing show whether a commercial product practices the claimed features, which is the coextensiveness question Manufacturing Resources turned on. 
  • Declarations that show their work. Lumenci’s expert testimony practice draws on 100+ experts who have supported 250+ litigations, with analysis built to meet 37 C.F.R. § 42.65 and hold up at deposition. 

For the first pass across large reference sets, Lumenci’s experts work with iLumOS, its expert-powered AI patent intelligence platform. Experts validate every finding before it goes into a chart or declaration. 

To pressure-test a petition or a patent owner response, talk to Lumenci’s IPR support team. 

Conclusion

An inter partes review is decided by the strength of the evidence behind the patentability or unpatentability of the challenged claims. A relevant reference, a proposed construction, or an obviousness rationale is not enough without a technically defensible explanation. 

For patent owners, strong technical analysis exposes weak mappings, tests proposed combinations, substantiates objective evidence, and supports amendments. For petitioners, it establishes where each limitation is disclosed, what the skilled person knew, and why the combination follows. In both cases, the advantage goes to the side whose claim language, technical evidence, and expert reasoning form one consistent record that holds up before the PTAB. 

Table of Contents
Let's Start a Conversation
Product Testing to Outcome

Frequently Asked Questions

What is inter partes review?

Inter partes review is a USPTO trial proceeding before the PTAB in which a third party challenges issued patent claims as anticipated or obvious, based only on prior art patents and printed publications. 

Since October 20, 2025, the USPTO Director decides institution in consultation with at least three PTAB judges, weighing discretionary factors and the merits. Instituted cases go to a three-judge panel for trial. 

The same standard district courts use: the ordinary and customary meaning to a person of ordinary skill in the art, read in light of the specification and prosecution history, under 37 C.F.R. § 42.100(b). 

No rule requires one, but most petitions and patent owner responses include one. Expert testimony that does not disclose its underlying facts or data gets little or no weight under 37 C.F.R. § 42.65(a). 

It is the element-by-element comparison of each claim limitation against the prior art, citing the exact passage, figure, or description that discloses it. In an IPR, the petition must identify where each element is found. 

As objective evidence of non-obviousness, but only with nexus to the claimed invention. A product must be coextensive with the claims to support a presumption of nexus, as Manufacturing Resources v. Squires (2026) shows. 

Yes. Under 35 U.S.C. § 316(d), the patent owner can propose a reasonable number of substitute claims that do not enlarge scope or add new matter. The petitioner bears the burden of showing they are unpatentable. 

Related Posts